Girl Interupted And Conflicting Perspectives

924 Words4 Pages
How does James Mangold shape his movie to explore a range of perspectives? Just like in Shakespeare’s “Julius Caesar”, James Mangold has shaped his movie “Girl Interrupted”, a story of a young woman signed into a mental institution, to explore a range of perspectives. Through his movie, Mangold has crossed the line of sanity into ideas of the insane, questioning the very idea of insanity. The audience witnesses the clash of perspectives between the world and the insane and within the minds of the insane themselves. Whether or not insanity is one thing experienced by Susanna, this conflict of views within the mind, is experienced by those medically diagnosed as “insane”. This however brings forward a range of conflicting perspectives on when can a person be classified as insane. One of the main themes within James Mangold’s movie is the confusion of social nonconformity with insanity. Mangold carefully skirts around the issue of whether Susanna was ever truly ill. His ambiguity exposes one of the central themes of the memoir: the line between sane and insane is a blurry one. It is through this vagueness that Mangold causes the audience to make their own decisions about the ideas put forward, thus shaping his movie to cover a range of perspectives. When Susanna confronts her diagnosis of borderline personality disorder, she questions the so-called “insane” actions of one afflicted. Charged with “uncertainty about long-term goals,” “instability of self-image,” and “social contrariness,” Lisa, Susana’s friend remarks that every teenager might satisfy these classifications, Susanna “borderline personality disorder… well that’s me.” Lisa “That’s every body.” Mangold here brings up a very important point. Who has the power to declare a person “crazy”. It is the people that move away from the social norms of the culture that are considered “weird”

More about Girl Interupted And Conflicting Perspectives

Open Document