Name: J Milbs
Issue Question: Can continuing to prosecute people like Darren Chiacchia for spreading the HIV virus be justified?
1. Premise One: If the Florida HIV laws are outdated, then continuing to prosecute people like Darren Chiacchia can no longer be justified. 1. If the Florida HIV laws are outdated, then the diagnosis of an HIV infection is no longer tantamount to a death sentence. 1. In 1997, Florida passed a law that makes it a felony for someone who is HIV positive to engage in any form of sexual intercourse without providing the partner with that information. 2. Failing to inform your partner that he/she is HIV positive with whom you are having sexual relations with in the state of Florida results in being charged with first degree murder. 3. At the time, the spreading of HIV infections was a major epidemic and resulted in a number of deaths from AIDS. 2. A diagnosis of an HIV infection is no longer tantamount to a death sentence, then continuing to prosecute people like Darren Chiacchia can no longer be justified.
1. Over the recent years technology has advanced and doctors have learned how to treat the HIV virus aggressively and extend the lives of those with AIDS.
2. Although the HIV infection cannot be cured, the infection can be managed for years a chronic disease.
3. People still die of AIDS, but their number is small compared with the number of people who are HIV positive.
2. Premise Two: The Florida HIV laws are outdated. 1. If the Florida HIV laws are unfair, then the Florida HIV laws are outdated.
1. The Florida HIV laws are based on a state of science and medicine that has now shifted.
2. Chiacchia is being charged with first degree murder for committing a crime that does not involve the use of a weapon or physical violence. 3. The sentence time for this crime greatly outweighs the reality of the