Comparative Analysis

432 Words2 Pages
Comparative Analysis The two texts, ”Antigua and Baruda”, an extract from a website and A Small Place, an essay written by local Jamaica Kincaid, describe the islands of Antigua and Baruda with very different tone. The formal and informative extract does nothing else than praises the islands as diverse holiday resort, while the essay even with its beautiful visual imagery has a more bitter tone. You, the motif of the essay is emphasized to the point, that it’s clear, that it is you, the tourist, who more than anyone likes the climate, which is “hot and dry for the four to ten days you are going to be staying there”. The sarcasm and criticism towards indifferent and inconsiderate tourists can be seen easily, as well as the contrast between tourists and local people. The tourists dislike rainfall during their holiday, while for the local inhabitants it could be a matter of survival. “[S]o you say, “Oh what a marvelous change these bad roads are from the highways I am used to in North America.” The Antigua Island described in the essay written in 1988 seems to have changed at the time when the extract is written. The island with bad roads has changed to the “the largest and most developed tourist destination in the Leeward Islands chain.” The extract, very similar to an advertisement, introduces a numerous places to visit on a holiday with warm and welcoming tone. It is structured clearly with short paragraphs and it is fast to read trough. Because of the tourist mobs, overprized food and “local bands who play infectious dance music”, it can be assumed that also the local inhabitants have better life standards not so dependent on weather like maybe in the essay in 1899. The extract mentions also the wild and barely inhabited Barbuda Island from which the essay tells nothing about. The situation and time in which the texts are written has probably affected most the
Open Document