Japan has the second highest suicide rate per 100,000 people in the world, according to a study by the Washington Post. The reason behind this ranking is clearly portrayed in the cause and effect status of the two texts Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior by Amy Chua and Suicide Note by Janice Mirikitani. Chua’s essay and Mirikitani’s poem go hand in hand with cause and effect, and the general ideas of this cause and effect are a cause for the high suicide rate in Japan as well as other Eastern countries. Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior by Amy Chua is written to inform readers of the parenting method differences between Eastern parents and Western parents, as well as persuade the readers that the Eastern methods are “superior” or more effective. One point that Chua makes is that Eastern parenting is the correct method of parenting because they do not take the psyche or self esteem of the child into consideration during critique.
The daughters disagree and believe divorce is ok. The Mothers belief stems from old Chinese culture while the daughters belief stems from American culture where divorces are very common. Another chinese belief the mothers believe that every women should be married. That conflicts with the american belief that a woman is not required to get married, this creates conflict among the daughters. The daughters of the members of the joy luck club grow up struggling to balance
For instance:“ A lot of people wonder how Chinese parents raise such stereotypically successful kids well I can tell them, Bachour 2 ! because I’ve done it, here are some things my daughters were never allowed to do… not play the piano or violin” (Chua 1). We have all had Chinese classmates; they always tend to be the smartest in the class, and we always wondered why are they the best !? Well in
There are distinct differences between the Chinese culture parenting style and the Western, but the key commonality is that both parents desire the success for their child’s future. Chua, starts her article by addressing the most common question. “How Chinese parents raise such stereotypically successful kids?”(Chau1). Her answer is quite simple: most of the things that other children are allowed to do, hers were not. Take playing an instrument for an example.
These two methods typically occur in two different cultures; western culture and Chinese culture. In the article “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior” by Amy Chua, a professor at Yale Law School, USA she discusses the differences on how Chinese mothers raise their children opposed to how western mothers raise theirs and she tells us why she thinks that the Chinese method has worked best for her. We know from the article that Amy Chua is Chinese and that she has grown up in a Chinese household. She therefore knows how it is to be raised by parents who use very strict guidelines and methods on their children in terms of raising them. However Amy Chua, and a huge variety of Chinese parents, mostly mothers, seemingly think that these methods actually work, and therefore use them on their own children.
Amy Chua has one statement that she uses “Chinese parents demand perfect grades because they believe that their child can get them” (p. 3 l 26) later in the article she add “Chinese parents can order their kids to get straight As… western parents can only ask their kids to they their best” (P 1, l 44). When she says that she indirectly means that Chinese parents are tougher than western parents. They don’t believe in their children, like Chinese parents do. They should rather make their child fell ashamed by using punishment, instead of always being careful and positive. Amy Chua gives a great example of the contrast between the cultures, she tell her readers how Chinese parents and western parents would react if their kid came home with an A minus “ the Chinese parent would gasp in horror and ask what went wrong” (p. 3 l 2) “A western parent would support and praise the child.” Later in the article Amy Chua comes with one of her statements, again“if a Chinese child gets a B – which would never happen” (p 3, l 21).
And mostly, the parents choose school and playing a classic instrument to be the first priorities. Her methods are very strict and hard – not funny and pedagogical like the most do it in the Western world. Amy Chua means that Western parents often are too soft with their children. If the kids want to give up at something, they respect that. She would keep pushing her children, and keep motivating them so they can achieve their goal, even if the kids doesn’t want do.
Adeline Yen Mah calls herself ‘Chinese Cinderella’ because so much of her life was like the life in the fairy tale. Like Cinderella, Adeline has to live by very strict ground rules; Adeline is not allowed to have friends over, or go to her friend’s houses as her stepmother clearly states on page27 “You are not allowed to invite any of your friends home, or to visit them in their houses.” This is similar to the fairy tale because Cinderella was not allowed to leave the kitchen. As stated before this quote clearly states, Adeline is not allowed to do much when it comes to friends. As you can see this is just one of the many ground rules Adeline and her siblings must live by. Throughout the book Adeline's stepmother is very unfair and cruel to her and her siblings.
"In America I will have a daughter just like me. But over there nobody will say her worth is measured by the loudness of her husband's belch. Over there nobody will look down on her, because I will make her speak only perfect American English" (3). This is extremely different from the older generation because when they were kids they were very independent and could not rely on their parents for help and support. A huge difference between the two generations is how outspoken they are.
Intention: To increase our understanding in the concept “Tiger Mom” and to shred light over why she thinks how “Chinese Mothers” are superior compared to “Western Mothers”. In providing examples and explanations about this, Amy Chua is correspondingly persuasive. This persuasiveness presents a positive point of view of the methods used by “Chinese Mothers,” and therefore is the intention in the article furthermore to influence the way “Western Mothers” raise their children. Essay China is a place far from us both geographically and culturally. Even though it is the most populous country, a country that represents approximately 18,5 % out of the earth’s inhabitant, they seem distant, distant in terms of belief, behaviour and ethics.