Case Study: Instant Takeover In Baseball

1049 Words5 Pages
Instant replay in baseball was close to being expanded for the 2012 season, but the decision to implement some changes was ultimately shelved in March. Deciding that rule changes shouldn't be made until MLB, the umpires and players determined which kinds of calls should be subject to review seemed like the right sentiment—especially when there probably wasn't enough time devoted to fully studying all of the possible issues at hand. Where do you draw the line? Los Angeles Dodgers manager Don Mattingly thinks instant replay should be expanded to cover game-ending plays. But what if a similarly disputable call occurs earlier in the game, yet ends up determining the final score? Should the umpiring crew on hand review disputed calls? Or should an official look at replays from the press box? What about the MLB office reviewing calls from league…show more content…
22, 2012 With the score tied 2-2 in the 11th inning, Texas Rangers infielder Alberto Gonzalez laid down a suicide squeeze bunt that brought home Nelson Cruz for the go-ahead run. What if Tim Welke's blown call affects the Tigers' playoff seeding? Leon Halip/Getty Images Except there was one problem. The ball ricocheted off Gonzalez's right leg before hitting the ground. The play should have been called a foul ball. Despite protests from Detroit Tigers manager Jim Leyland and several of his players, the call stood and the Rangers went on to win. Replays clearly showed the ball hitting Gonzalez's leg. See for yourself. There was no signal in dispute this time. Home plate umpire Tim Welke simply didn't see the ball hit Gonzalez and ruled the ball fair. However, upon seeing a replay after the ballgame, Welke told reporters that the ball did indeed hit Gonzalez. He didn't go so far as to say the play should have been called foul since he, nor any of his fellow umpires, saw the ball hit Gonzalez. But whether he admits it or not, Welke essentially said he made the wrong

More about Case Study: Instant Takeover In Baseball

Open Document