Case Study: How Title IX Discriminates Against Male Athletes

2697 Words11 Pages
THE CASE FOR REFORM: How Title IX Discriminates against Male Athletes Introduction: In 1997, the men’s wrestling team at San Francisco University had won the team title for NCAA Division II Wrestling Championships. As the years progressed, Head Coach Lars Jensen was determined to defend the team’s national title but this time with a serious handicap. Because of Title IX, Jensen was forced to cap his roster to 22 athletes, cutting California State High School Champion and two California state place winners. Title IX is destroying men’s teams all over the Country. Many male athletes are being deprived the right to participate in their desired sport. What these students have worked toward their entire lives has been taken away from them…show more content…
Individuals, coaches, and clubs, have brought equal protection claims against many institutions having selfishly destroyed men’s teams, but courts seem to be reluctant. For a valid equal protection claim (EPC), "a plaintiff must allege in the pleadings that the government intentionally discriminated against [them] by classifying him or her for different treatment under the law than one similarly situated" (Bentley pg. 9). This notion seems to be paradoxical, having courts decisions endorsing the elimination of men’s games. There is a continuing rejection of court cases involving the violations of Title IX using the EPC method, proving that reform is necessary. One way to ensure that no person is denied their athletic ability to participate in a sport would be to interpret Title IX in a way that is similar to the codes and regulations of the Equal Pay Act (EPA). They are different in which Title IX prohibits sex discrimination in education with regards to college athletic participation while EPA prohibits sex discrimination regarding work payment in employment. Despite these differences, they are both aimed towards prohibiting sex

More about Case Study: How Title IX Discriminates Against Male Athletes

Open Document