Carla's Story Case Study

2138 Words9 Pages
Carla’s Life through Relational Lenses By: Tara Bray Assignment 1 N352 February 24, 2009 N352, Section A01 University of Victoria Carla’s Story Throughout this paper I will communicate my initial views on Carla’s Scenario, the immediate assumptions made about her family context, my theoretical viewpoint on the situation, and how the theoretical lenses may be used out in practice. Initial Thoughts After reading the scenario on Carla’s family I thought her life seemed pretty standard. Especially since every family has their own unique problems and truth be told there is no such thing as a normal family. The first thing that stood out for me after reading the scenario was Carla’s genuine concern for her…show more content…
I assumed that Carla was responsible although she could be doing everything she did only because she had been told to do so or possibly she could have been lying about the things she said. It would be hard for me to know the difference between her realities or what she falsely claimed as true, and there could be many other factors which we don’t see that say she was not a responsible person. With Carla’s gender I automatically thought she would be more mature and caring than her brother because she was female, and usually girls mature faster than boys, or so I have been told over the years. I believed automatically that their socio-economic status was middle class because her family could afford to travel for months and send two kids to University, and that is not cheap. Carla’s weight was not that big of a concern for me because I thought it was the stress from her brother causing her to be underweight; I took this assumption directly from my own situation of living with an older brother. Looking back I realize that many of these assumptions may not be Carla’s…show more content…
Using a critical lens draws explicit attention to power, social in equalities, and structural determinants of health (Doane and Varcoe, 2005, p. 60). Everything Carla knows may be because of where she grew up and the societal and historical values which have been instilled in her. Through a critical lens we may question why Carla was worried about her brother, maybe she had seen his behavior before in another loved one or was she programmed through her history to be an overly protective person? And why was she not worried about her weight, was this the size her mom was? Was the media making her believe that she must be thin? Carla’s actions may have been because “all knowledge is shaped by socially and historically shaped power relations (Doane and Varcoe, p. 54).” By knowing this we may begin to see her views on the situation and her
Open Document