Camparing and Contrasting the Cask of Amantillado and Eveline

306 Words2 Pages
There are several similarities between the short stories The Cask of Amontillado and Eveline and there are also some differences. The most glaring similarities that I noticed is the use of descriptive words throughout both stories particularly describing damp and dusty odors and setting. Eveline’s room smells of dusty cretonne which is somewhat of an unpleasant odor, and her home is rather rundown, much like the unpleasant and rundown feel of the vaults in the Cask of Amontillado. Also in both stories the main character has devised a plan that will be ruined if a certain person finds out. Eveline plans to run away with Frank and her father must not know, and Montresor plans to kill Fortunato so he obviously can’t find that out. Also both stories are offering relatable examples of human nature. In Eveline, we see realate to dreams of independence yet comfort of old habits, and in The Cask we relate to the desire for revenge. While these stories both have similarities, they also have many differences. First of all, the settings are different. Eveline takes place in Dublin and the Cask of Amontillado takes place in Italy. Another major difference is the stories points of view. Eveline is told from the third person and the Cask of Amontillado is told from the first person. The cask of Amontillado is a story of murder and revenge, while Eveline is a story about dreaming of independence yet not being able to let go of old ways. In conclusion, these two stories have distinct similarities and differences. While the differences of each story are obvious, the most important aspect of these two stories is the similar fact that each offers an interesting critique on human behavior, specifically as it pertains to how we deal with old habit and also how humans desire

More about Camparing and Contrasting the Cask of Amantillado and Eveline

Open Document