Boy Girl Essay

1225 Words5 Pages
Written Assignment #3: As Nature Made Him: The Boy Who Was Raised as a Girl As Nature Made Him is a phenomenal story about a medical tragedy and its traumatic outcome. After a botched circumcision, a family decides to raise their infant son, Bruce, as a girl. They rename the child Brenda and spend the next 14 years trying to transform him into a her. Brenda’s childhood dealt with much anxiety and loneliness. Her fear and confusion regarding her gender are present on almost every page of this book. I chose this story, simply based on the title. The title is what mainly caught my attention. “The Boy Who Was Raised as a Girl” should attract everyone’s eyes. I was interested in learning how the parents went about this and the ups and downs in this child’s life. I mainly wanted to know how this transformation altered this person’s adulthood. A major concept of this story that was noticeable to me was the argument of nature versus nurture. I felt that the theory of nature versus nurture was majorly incorporated into this story; showing a person brought up a way that contradicts with his biological genes. In 1965, a young Canadian couple, Ron and Janet Reimer, gave birth to twin boys. When the babies were eight months old, they were taken to St. Boniface Hospital in Winnipeg, Manitoba, for what should have been a routine surgical procedure. Both boys suffered from phimosis, a relatively common condition in which the foreskin of the penis seals at the tip, making urination painful. Their pediatrician had recommended a simple solution: circumcision. After fumbling around a couple of times with the electric current on a cautery device, Dr. Jean-Marie Huot, a general practitioner, began slicing away at Bruce's foreskin -- and seared off the rest of the penis along with it. Bruce Reimer had his penis practically burned off. Watching television one night in 1967,
Open Document