He has represented the Internet as the answer to all of society's worries. In both these articles both writers provide very convincing evidence weather on how the Internet is making us more brilliant or is it turning us brainless. In Nicholas Carr’s Article “Does the Internet Make You Dumber?” he argues the fact that the Internet indeed does make you “dumber,” almost scaring its reader to stay away from web usage. He takes a more scientific approach talking about how the Internet allows us to have a mass amount of information at any time, but with all that info comes distractions. He goes on about how those distractions hurt our mental thinking.
Is Google Making Us Stupid? Criticism of the Web most often questions whether we are becoming more superficial and scattered in our thinking. Some see the change as a loss, not as a gain. Some would say that the Web is the greatest humanizing impact in the World. The World Wide Web has changed the way we think and how we live our everyday lives, but is it molding our lives?
However, Google has a huge amount of information and much of it could be wrong. For example, the Wikipedia website is not a good source of information because normal people write the information in it and not specialists. Therefore, if we get wrong information, then our knowledge would be wrong. Carr also discussed that the Internet is an imaginary world, and all the people are behind the computer screens. Therefore, whenever we access a website, Google can collect more information about us, and if we access more websites, then that would be easier and faster for them to collect the information they want.
Viehmann English 112 Google: The Fast and Arguable Resource In Nicholas Carr’s article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid,” he talks about how he had difficulties researching while reading books and long articles. He discusses on how the Internet effects our thinking, reading, writing, and how our brains react to get used to the new media. Carr attempts to provoke the reader with negative effects that result from Internet use. Carr uses some specific examples, and figures, to demonstrate his point of view on online researching. From Carr's opening paragraph, he gives a rough understanding on his skewed view, comparing Stanley Kubrick's film 2001: A Space Odyssey to his own personal emotion of becoming mentally disconnected.
They may become so used to communicating via internet that they lose basic communication skills and can’t hold a face to face conversation. Prior to social media, people were able to have secret affairs. But now, it has become so much easier to trace foot prints that are left behind, which in turn makes it easier for couples to spy on each other. Sharing passwords, setting rules as to who your significant other can and can’t have on their friends list, or even going as far as making them delete social media all together will cause many problems between insecure couples. In general, relationships can be greatly affected both positively and
Perhaps the sensational changes in the technological world might raise divergent opinions on the fate of the current generation. Philosophers in particular are perturbed by the way the internet is wasting away the traditional methods of research and the natural intelligence of the mortal man. In Carr’s essay; ‘Is Google making us stupid?’ Carr alludes from Socrates’ view that people would be thought of as, “having knowledge when they are actually illiterate due to the unorganized internet knowledge.” It is also a worry by scholars that the internet may at great extend induce laziness amongst students on a claim that they will lose the habit of looking for books and reading them (Carr 533-541). Carr is particularly worried that his level of concentration is not to the maximum. The author admits that when goggling, he would sometimes, “sneak into other pages because of some attractive features or because of curiosity and forget about his work.” However, his opinion is baseless as internet - Google in specific - will actually sharpen the society’s knowledge and expound their level of thinking (Carr 533-541).
In an article written by Nicholas Carr “Is Google Making Us Stupid”? A widely circulated article and in the book that followed, The Shallows (2010), The main point of this article brings up the question of whether the quick access to information on the Internet has led to us becoming more “impatient”. Carr argues that the “media are not just passive channels of information. They supply the stuff of thought, but they also shape the process of thought.” He alleges that the internet is changing the way one thinks to an increasingly shallow way that is, unreflecting and blandly standardized. Carr uses 3 illustrative anecdotes to make his argument of how technology has drastically changed our way of being not only in the way we think but also in the way we operate as human being’s.
Also digital culture and social media had made they forgot about the reality and live in a virtual life. “The Dumbest Generation” that wrote by Mark Bauerlein is one example. Bauerlein believes that digital culture and social media had cut young adults away from history, civic, literature, and fine arts. However, I have the opposite opinion; believe that digital culture actually made young adults smarter in different ways. There are many famous people including Bauerlein himself were having an argument with another group of people on whether digital culture is an advantage or not.
Stupidity or Just Mere Laziness Is Google really making us stupid or are we just getting more and more lazier and being dependent on it. In his 2008 article at Atlantic Magazine, “Is Google Making us Stupid?”, Nicholas G. Carr, an American writer who has published books and articles on technology, business, and culture, talks about how the Internet is changing our mind works and the negative effect the Internet has in our lives. Carr believes that the problem stems from our extensive use of Internet that it is reshaping the way we read, learn, interact with others and express ourselves. With his article, Carr targets the people who use Internet a lot but grew up without the technologies that we have today and can even live without it especially the highly educated and intellectual people. His main argument on the article is to show his reader how’s the Internet is changing the way our mind works, how it remaps the neural circuitry and reprogram the memory of our brain (Carr 1).
Is Google really making us stupid or are we just getting more and more lazy and being reliant on it. In his 2008 article at Atlantic Magazine, “Is Google Making us Stupid?”, Nicholas G. Carr, an American writer who has published books and articles on technology, business, and culture, talks about how the Internet is shifting the way our brain works and the harmful result the Internet has in our lives. Carr believes that the problem stems from our widespread use of the internet that it is reshaping the approach we read, learn, interact with others and express ourselves. With his article, Carr targets the people who use Internet a lot but grew up without the technologies that we have today and can even live without it especially the highly educated and intelligent individuals. His main argument on the article is to show his reader how the Internet is shifting the way our mind works, how it remaps the neural reprogram the memory of our brain.