Areas of Conflict and Co-Operation - Uk Gov't and Scottish Gov't

1572 Words7 Pages
Areas of Conflict and Co-operation exist between Holyrood and Westminster. Discuss. Holyrood and Westminster are said to have a good relationship, built on co-operation. However, from day one, elements of conflict and confrontation have steadily grown to be an equally large factor between Holyrood and Westminster. Finance, legislation and devolution seem to be at the very core of everything in the world of UK and Scottish politics, but just how much do Holyrood and Westminster actually get on? Legislation plays a key role in the relationship between Holyrood and Westminster and can sometimes cause breakdowns involving the two, and in 1998 the UK Government announced that a convention would be established so that Westminster would not normally legislate on devolved matters in Scotland without the consent of the Scottish Parliament. This was called the “Sewel Motion”, now a Legislative Consent Motion and proved to be a huge success between the two governments. Scottish Ministers can also provide support to UK Government Ministers. This happened under the leadership of the former Labour First Minister Jack McConnell as he felt that it would be appropriate for the Scottish Government to give aid to Malawi. Jack McConnell also gave Westminster the approval to vote on whether gay marriage should be passed or not, as he did not want the responsibility or repercussions to be on him. Legislation may be a key role but it is not always a role in which many things are agreed. Politicians from Holyrood haven’t always seen eye to eye with those from Westminster and in prior to the devolution referendum in 1979 this was proven to be the case. A Labour MP, - from West Lothian - Tam Dalyell, expressed concerns about the creation of a Scottish Parliament, simply because he felt that Scottish MPs at Westminster would lose influence and power over issues which would affect their

More about Areas of Conflict and Co-Operation - Uk Gov't and Scottish Gov't

Open Document