Am I a Bad Person

617 Words3 Pages
Carefully read and analyze the essay by Hochswender on pp. 153-155 in your Muller & Wiener textbook. After considering how Hochswender uses the features of argument you have learned so far, compose a thread explaining whether you do or do not find his essay persuasive. Use evidence from the essay to support your opinion, and strive to find a balance between pathos, ethos, and logos appeals in your thread. The essay, “Did My Car Join Al Qaeda?” by Woody Hochswender was very persuasive. By using pictorial images, and humane gestures he easily seduces his audience to think and see as he does. Hochswender drives a large SUV. In this passage of writing he tries to persuade his audience that because his choice of transportation requires a lot of gas, it does not mean he is a bad person. This assumption was noted by the Virtuous One, who according to the text, “insists that America’s fuel consumption is somewhat responsible for the enmity towards us and the Middle East”(Muller, G. &Wiener, H. 2009, pg.154). The authors tone here can be heard as one of judgment by the “Virtuous One”. “How can they can they (SUV drivers) call themselves citizens of the United States, peacemakers, and driver such big gas guzzlers?” “They are the reason for the high gas prices”. No one likes to be judged, and Hochswender uses this as an advantage to his claim. He intentionally uses September 11th as an ethical (ethos) appeal. In his statement, “Those who implicate America for 9-11, validate the terrorist as essentially right” (Muller.G. et.al pg. 154). How can you be for something and blame them at the same time? It is unethical to say that because you drive an SUV, this is an indication that you agree with 9-11 or that you are a terrorist! Joshua asked the question in Joshua 5:13(NIV) “Are you for us or against us”. You cannot be both. Your syllogistic reasoning must

More about Am I a Bad Person

Open Document