Ali Jinnah Two Nation Theory

266 Words2 Pages
Natalie Wright 4/29/13 History 290SA Discussion Paper 5 Md. Ali Jinnah argued that his “two nation theory” would be the best option to maintain order and freedom within India. He believed that in order for a united democratic government to work, minorities in the country must feel supported as he states that if the minorities don’t feel secure under the government, “no proper constitution will last but result in a revolution and a civil war” (227). Rather than merge Hindus along with other minorities, Jinnah also believes it is best if both cultures accept each others’ differences and remain independent from one another. Jinnah asserts that Hindus and Muslims cannot simply coexist under a unified rule because their cultures and backgrounds are so distinct. According to the British, their “superstitions” would eventually “die out” (229). However, Jinnah explains that these so-called “superstitions” are actually deep-rooted “spiritual, economic, cultural, social, and political” (229), differences. Hindus and Muslims are not only different in their religious beliefs, but in their customs, values, and way of life. Since they also have different societal expectations, customs, and literature, the linkage of the two would only result in unhappiness. A government that cannot recognize and accommodate the differences in either culture cannot successfully function, and will actually harm the British and Hindus as well. Jinnah also believes that the unification of Hindus and Muslims, “ can only mean Hindu rule” (231). Hindus will become the dominant group, and the “minorities” will suffer oppression. Jinnah believes that Muslims constitute a recognizable nation that deserves its own property and
Open Document