A Different History by Sujatta Bhatt Analysis

1626 Words7 Pages
The author of this enigmatic yet still utterly fascinating poem, Sujata Bhatt was brought up in Pune, India until 1968, when she and her family moved to the USA. Bhatt is now currently living in Bremen, Germany with her husband, Michael Augustin, and her daughter. Bhatt immediately grabs the reader’s attention with the title "A Different History". It draws us in. What makes it so different? It ignites a will to find out what is so different. A belief? Is it her take on history? Does it contain information about her? The only way to find out her answer is to ask her; but we can guess, can we not? The poetess while writing this poem has given importance to the culture and various religions in India. She has emphasized in her poem by repeating words and questions and thereby making her poem stronger. She writes about Indian traditions, lost identities, importance of language, cultural difference to create different moods and themes. In the first part of the poem, she concentrates on respect for education and learning. She claims that in Indian religion every object is sacred. There is God in trees. You should treat your books as the goddess of knowledge. You should be gentle when turning the pages of the book that you read for knowledge of religion. The first line creates a deeper sense of intrigue opening with the statement, "Great Pan is not dead;" as it isn't phrased as an opinion, but as a statement and is said in a firm tone. She has used a semi-colon to show that her thought isn't finished, that she has more to say. This line plants the idea of the rising of a dead religion, the Greek into my head. I use "dead" because the Greek Gods are no longer worshipped widely in Greece. I think this because Great Pan, the Greek god of nature, was stated to have been one of the only Greek Gods to have died. By her saying that Pan is not dead there is a chance that
Open Document