Robot Domination In Brian Aldiss's Short Story Who Can Replace A Man

594 Words3 Pages
Sarah Yost Mr. Massey Period 3-4 10/4/12 Robot Domination Humans rely too much on robotic machines. Robots should not be able to communicate or act like humans on their own. Brian Aldiss, the author who wrote the short story “Who Can Replace a Man” demonstrates how without humans the robots would take over our world. Brian shows how a group of bots try to overcome a problem of no orders by going on a long and treacherous journey in order to fix or build a new orderly system. “’We will speak to each other. This lack of orders is unprecedented. Have you further information on it,’ said the penner” (Aldiss 224-225). This short story is set in the future, in a very inhumane setting. There is also a loose inspection plate above the nuclear pile for the bots. Humans wouldn’t be able to survive with it. The big conflict is when the robots go berserk and get destroyed or destroy things. Also in Who Can Replace a Man Brian demonstrates how robots are the new humans by having them do human work.…show more content…
“Get me food,’ he croaked” “Yes, Master,’ said the machines” (Aldiss 233). The robots are classified by how their brains are wired. Class one being the smartest, being a human, and class 10 being the dumbest, a bot. People are not classified by brain types but by the knowledge they have. Without the knowledge and the brain robots wouldn’t be able to have emotions, therefore they couldn’t fight and argue with one another. In the short story the bots get themselves into an argument and fight in the city destroying humans and themselves. If the robots didn’t have any classified brains they wouldn’t have been able to get themselves into that situation. Robots need to not take on life themselves. They need to rely on us humans. Therefore when we do become extinct, the robots will know how to run without us in a proper
Open Document