What Is Magic in Cinderella

1119 Words5 Pages
What Is Magic in Cinderella? As to the meaning of magic in Cinderella, there always remain lots of arguments among readers. For instance, Bruno Bettelhem tries to convince people that the magic is a metaphor for psychological development, while Jack Zips then criticizes that the psychoanalytic theory that Bettelheim uses to demonstrate his argument is to some extend a gimmick. Max Luthi implies in his The Isolated Hero that magic serves as an important power that helpers have, helping fairytale heroes who are neither characteristic nor owning any specific skills performing their tasks. Madonna Kolbenschlag considers the magic in Cinderella as a symbol of faith and trust that heroine needs, “the belief that something good can be gained from whatever one does.” Jane Yolen suggests that the true magic refer to “the ability to change our own lives, the ability to control our own lives.” However, in my opinion, magic in Cinderella is first of all an outcome of real lives, and then a kind of reflection of people’s old religious beliefs. To begin with, Cinderella stories belong to fairytales, and fairytales are stories with supernatural imaginations. However, those imaginations are never merely fantasies, that is to say, authors of fairytales must base their imaginations upon the reality, or their fairytales will never be accepted by people. This is why Cinderella stories in different regions appear to be different versions although they almost share a same motif. Take The Chinese “Cinderella” and Charles Perrault’s Cinderella as an example. First, the setting of The Chinese “Cinderella” is in ancient China, while Cinderella is in ancient Europe. So the acquaintance occasion of “Cinderella” and “Prince” is respectively the cave-festival and the ball. Then, the magic presenting in the former one is the fish and that man “with his hair loose over his shoulders and

More about What Is Magic in Cinderella

Open Document