Transcript Analysis on the Differences Between Male and Female Speak

618 Words3 Pages
Transcript Analysis on the Differences Between Male and Female Speak. Firstly, this transcript highlights many interesting issues about language and gender. However, it is important to consider the context of the transcript as it is taken from a chat show presented and led by women, often discussing issues about men and how women are treated in society. The given transcript contradicts typical and expected traits of female versus male speech in more ways than one. An example includes the way in which our female speaker (Germaine Greer) appears to make an attempt at initiating conflict through the use of pragmatics, “what we’ve been trying to do is civilise the talk show”. The simple mention of the point makes it seem as though she is being ironic, as an attempt to be civil wouldn’t usually include a mention of previous criticisms being made, “avoiding slanging matches”. At this point the text must be contextualised, as if the chat show had taken place in the 1920’s rather than the modern day, women acting in this dominant, almost mocking way would have been seen as completely unacceptable. As the transcript contains a male speaker as well as two female speakers, we’re also able to analyse how the male’s speech steers away from the norm, or expected. Our male speaker (Alan Clark) drifts away from the usual dominant, interruptive style of speech that we’d usually expect from a male and appears almost uncomfortable in speaking, especially due to his use of repetition, “but but your your” indicating that he feels hesitant in his words. It can be argued that the presence of no other males could be the cause of this; the male feels nervous and intimidated due to being in the minority compared to females, and therefore doesn’t conform to the usual way we’d expect a male to speak“. According to Tannen, when it comes to spoken language males are more likely to contradict
Open Document