To What Extent Has Modern Liberalism Departed from the Ideas of Classical Liberalism?

849 Words4 Pages
To what extent has Modern Liberalism departed from the ideas of Classical Liberalism? Modern Liberalism first emerged after around 1870 as a reaction to further industrialisation and the problems that came with it. Whilst having some contrasting views, Modern Liberals still share some ideology with that of the more Classical Liberals. Classical Liberals view the individual as a self-reliant and self-interested being who merely seeks pleasure from life. Classical Liberals were largely influenced by Jeremy Bentham and his idea of utilitarianism, they argue that individuals act in a way that will gain them ultimate pleasure and happiness, of which they alone judge the quality and are free from any paternal authority. Individuals were to make decisions themselves based on what gave them more or less utility. John Stuart Mill also shared the belief that no authority has the right to claim they know more about the individual’s interests. This leads to the belief in a minimal state that should only make decisions based on the greatest happiness. Modern Liberals, however, see the individual as somebody who is driven by self-development as opposed to an egoistic being. They see Bentham’s ideas as being shallow and believe it isn’t as simple to categorise actions into either ‘pleasure’ or ‘pain’. There is more of an emphasis on reaching your full potential as opposed to gaining the ultimate pleasure and J S Mill also believed in developing the individual and that there are ‘higher’ and ‘lower’ pleasures which need to be taken into consideration. Sometimes pain is necessary to reach an overall pleasure, as J S Mill said, it’s “better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied..”. There is a clear move away from Classical Liberalism in terms of utilitarianism and the focus purely being on gaining pleasure from all of your decisions. Modern Liberals see the
Open Document