Sunflower-Simon Wiesenthal Essay

1026 Words5 Pages
Sunflower Response In the book, The Sunflower, Simon Wiesenthal writes of an incident occurring when he was a Nazi concentration camp prisoner. Barely surviving himself, and while on a work detail, a nurse summons Wiesenthal to the hospital bed of a young and dying Nazi soldier, Karl, who seeks forgiveness from a Jew for the atrocities and murders he carried out against them. Wiesenthal had to decide at the moment, when he was by Karl’s side, whether or not to forgive him. He left the soldier’s side without saying a word. The next day, the nurse who had summoned Wiesenthal the day before told him Karl had died. In 1946, having survived the war, Wiesenthal decides to find Karl’s mother in Stuttgart. Widowed, grieving and alone, she tells Wiesenthal her son was a “good boy.” Wiesenthal says nothing of the murderer her son became, knowing she would not have believed him. Then Wiesenthal, at the conclusion of his story, asks the reader to imagine themselves in his place and ask, “What would I have done?” Fifty-three well-known men and women, from all walks of life, respond. To Wiesenthal’s question, the writer, Yossi Klein Halevi, believes Wiesenthal did the right thing by not telling Karl’s mother the truth about her son. She had lost everything except her pride in Karl. Halevi surmises the reason Wiesenthal did not take vengence on Karl’s mother was because whatever evil Karl did in the past, cannot be a reason for Wiesenthal to take his anger out on Karl’s mother at that place and time. Halevi, the son of Holocaust survivors, had a hard time understanding this simple message —“refusal to forgive belongs to that time and place, not ours,” (Sunflower pg. 164) and tried to separate himself from anything German until he traveled as a journalist to Germany after the Berlin Wall fell. Experiencing German youth as so intimidated by the Holocaust, Halevi felt the
Open Document