Six Piece Poem Comparsion Essay

1912 Words8 Pages
Harry Guest October 2013 IGCSE Literature Poetry Coursework War Photographer by Once Upon a Time by Carol Ann Duffy Gabriel Okara Piano by Poem at Thirty-Nine by D.H Lawrence Alice Walker A Mother in a Refugee Camp by Half-past Two by Chinua Achebe U.A. Fanthorpe Title: Explore how different poets treat the subject of memories, referring to the six poems from your wider reading. ‘Memories warm you up from the inside. But they also tear you apart.’ (Haruki Murakami 1949 – present) Haruki Murakami’s words relate to all six of the poems that I have studied which explain both good and bad memories. ‘War Photographer’ and ‘Mother in a Refugee Camp’ are both melancholy poems with either memories they wish to forget or memories they can never forget because they are so distressing, ‘Once Upon a Time’ and ‘Poem at Thirty-Nine’ are from the perspective of a personae looking back and remembering their childhood. ‘Half-past Two’ and ‘Piano’ are similarly both child-based with naïve and innocent approaches to the past. Memories can be pleasant, warming and remind us of happy times, but they can also be sad, ominous and unpleasant things dragging up forgotten pasts and terrible nightmares. ‘War Photographer’, is an upsetting poem consisting mainly of contrasts between the idyllic ‘Rural England’ and the war torn countries ‘fields which explode beneath the feet’ he is photographing. Similarly, ‘Piano’ includes contrasts between his memories ‘A child sitting under a piano’ and now ‘I weep like a child for the past’ this line also displays a different side of the Lawrence’s poem, a much more sombre tone. But ultimately unlike ‘War Photographer’, ‘Piano’ is a much happier poem with cheerful memories of childhood. Both poets use very different types of memories but both show the emotional effect these memories, these
Open Document