Singer Solution Essay

1145 Words5 Pages
Hailey Nichols The Singer Solution In Peter Singer’s mind, the 19,000 people that die per day from illnesses attributed to poverty die at the hands of American consumers. Peter Singer argues this in his essay The Singer Solution to World Poverty. Singer supports his claim by his solution, which states “…whatever money you're spending on luxuries, not necessities, should be given away”. Singer believes this is our moral responsibility and those who don’t give aren’t morally sound. There is no way that Singer can force anyone to donate money, so for persuasion, he creates two hypothetical situations in his favor to help you decide if you want to donate or not. Bob parked his Bugatti by a railroad track and set out to take a walk. He saw a runaway train speeding down the tracks that was heading towards a small child. Bob had the choice to flip a switch, which will redirect the train away from the child and towards his Bugatti. Bob decided not to flip the switch and as a result the child died, but his Bugatti wasn’t harmed. Dora persuaded a homeless 9-year-old boy to follow her to an address she has been given. She delivered the boy, received her reward, spent some money on a television set went home to enjoy. Her neighbor then tells her that the boy was too old to be adopted and that the plan was to sell his organs. Dora feels very conflicted, and decides to get the boy back. These situations pull on you heart strings and succeed for many in convincing them to donate. In my opinion, the argument loses its strength as the essay goes on and the reader becomes less persuaded to donate when Singer begins to demand that people donate every thing they earn that they don’t use for necessities. Singer says “We seem to lack a sound basis for drawing a clear moral line between Bob's situation and that of any reader of this article with $200 to spare who does not

More about Singer Solution Essay

Open Document