Romeo and Juliet Comparison Essay, Zefferli and Luhrmann's Version

714 Words3 Pages
Homesh Krishnamoorthy Mrs. Nelson English 9E 10/04/2012 Comparison Paragraph between Franco Zeffirelli and Baz Luhrmann In Act 3 scene 1 of Romeo and Juliet, Franco Zeffirelli and Baz Luhrmann portray a differing interpretation of the scene. Based on my opinion of the play I believe Zeffirelli portrays a stronger interpretation of the themes and deeper ideas of the play based on characterization, setting, and the interpretation of the lines. To begin with, Zeffirelli accurately portrays the characters Mercuito, Benvolio and Tybalt by showing the audience how Mercutio is always making jokes and laughing around, and Benvolio being cautious of a fight. This leaves us with Tybalt, who is fierce and short-tempered, always looking to bring up a battle. In the beginning of the scene, Benvolio says to Mercutio, “I pray thee, Good Mercutio, let’s retire” (Benvolio 3.1.1), Mercutio abruptly interrupts him while saying “Blah, Blah, Blah” (Mercutio 3.1.2). The lines that Mercutio had used to interfere with Benvolio’s lines were not in the script that Shakespeare wrote in 1595, and were added by Zeffirelli. Mercutio’s humor is seen with the lines “Thou hast quarreled with a man for coughing in the street, because he hath wakened thy dog that hath lain asleep in the sun” (Mercutio 23-26). Mercutio talks about having a fight with someone because that person had woken up a dog that was sleeping in the sun. However, the characterization the Luhrmann’s movie is off compared to Zeffirelli’s. Mercutio is again a comedian, aided with the precautious Benvolio on his side, but Mercutio could be considered more serious and aggressive when he says “Consort? What, dost thou make us minstrels? An’ thou make minstrels of us, look to hear nothing but discords. Here’s my fiddlestick; here’s that shall make you dance. Zounds, consort!” (Mercutio 3.1.45-48). These exact lines were said a
Open Document