Of Justice in Plato’s “Republic”

1093 Words5 Pages
Matthew Antunes Mid-term PHL 101 Intro to Philosophy 10/24/12 1. One’s search for the meaning of justice in Plato’s “Republic” would finally lead to two definitions, Justice is Harmony. (Book 4, 434c). Justice is doing one’s own job. (book 4, 443b) Finding these two phrases, however, is hardly enough to get a clear sense of what justice is. Plato offers two main analogies to examine the definition of justice. The division of parts in the soul as well as the parts of the state we would now examine the structure of the soul. The soul is divided into three parts, the appetitive, spirited and the rational. The appetitive is the part “with which it lusts, hungers, thirsts and gets excited by other appetites” (Book 4, 439d). The rational part is the part in the soul that calculates, makes balanced decisions having the good of the whole soul as its interest. The third part is the spirited, the part of the soul that is courageous, vigorous and strong willed. The spirited naturally, if “it hasn’t been corrupted by a bad upbringing” (Book 4, 441a). The state is also divided into three types of people, the workers, soldiers and the rulers. It is pretty obvious that sort of division seems awkward when we look at our own capitalist society. We have to keep in mind that in the republic that Plato is describing that each person is directed lead by education and the utmost care towards the work that they are to do all there might. The children in Plato’s republic are separated from their parents at birth and therefore get the same equal chance of becoming workers or rulers without any prejudice or family background getting in the way. The workers are the people that are best fitted to practice a specific form of labor. The soldiers are the people that are best fitted to fight, people that are spirited and that pass the tests of the state by holding firmly to the
Open Document