My Antonia Essay

1103 Words5 Pages
Over the years, critics have mauled any and every writer they could get their pens on. They critique everything about the writer, including his or her works. For example, Willa Cather’s novel, My Antonia, is highly criticized by many critics. It is mainly criticized for its cyclical themes with no structure that hold the books of the novel together. My Antonia is a collection of five different accounts remembered by the main character, Jim Burden. It is characterized by a loose plot structure; however, it is the common themes of cyclical nature that holds the novel together. My Antonia has been referred to as a novel that is “defective in structure” (Bloom 51). Its structure is based upon Cather’s point of view, which tells the story of the main character, Jim Burden, who recounts certain moments in his life in an abstract pattern about his Antonia. The collection of books that make up the novel is about Willa Cather’s idea of what and to what extent Jim Burden remembers. The novel is also said to be one that “lacks focus and abounds in irrelevancies” (Wells 1). This is a direct result from Cather’s inability to provide a consistent character portrayal throughout her novel. On the same note, My Antonia is said to have many “variations from a theme” (Wells 1). An example of that would be when Peter and Pavel, two lonesome Russian settlers, tell Jim and Antonia a tragic tale that horrifies the children. This is the tale of when Peter and Pavel drove a sled with a bridal couple across the dark and snowy country side and were attacked by savage wolves, where both the bride and groom were killed by the wolves. This example is what could be referred to as “divergences which weaken the overall structure of the novel” (Wells 1). Despite the fact that critics say the novel has a loose structure, critics also say that the novel has one thing that slightly resembles a
Open Document