MIRICALE ON ST DAVID DAY AND AN UNKNOWN GIRL

1392 Words6 Pages
I am going to compare “Miracle on St David Day” and “An Unknown Girl”. I chose these two poems because they both focus on the memory of a specific event. An “Unknown Girl”, by Moniza Alvi is a poem that will catch our attention. It's about the experience of being a female but mostly finding our identity and who we really are. Moniza Alvi was born in Lahore, Pakistan, and came to England when she was a few months old. The poem describes the poets visit to India and the time she had her hand hennaed by a girl in the market place. This for example was for her an unforgettable experience. As we read the poem, Moniza Alvi describes the scene. She describes everything in her sight using most likely metaphors. “Miracle on St. David's day” by Gillian Clarke is about a 'miracle' that occurs on St. David's Day, when a dumb man is touched by the power of a poem. The poet, Gillian Clarke, visits a mental hospital and recites poems to the patients. One of the poems that Gillian Clarke reads is called 'The Daffodils' by William Wordsworth. The continuous theme running throughout Gillian Clarke's poem is the healing power of nature and how nature can even cure the damaged minds of people who were thought of as incurable. Gillian Clarke finds nature of great importance. This may be the reason she reads the poem 'The Daffodils' at the mental hospital in the first place. In An Unknown Girl,there are several themes in this poem; cultural identity, sense of belonging, loss and the relationship between the familiar and the unknown. In this poem there are obvious links between Western and Eastern culture. There is a sense of the purity of the 'unknown girl', perhaps representing the innocence of India, being invaded by the Western culture. There are constant reminders of the beauty of India. For example when she talks about the peacock in line 16: Peacocks are exotic, and there is

More about MIRICALE ON ST DAVID DAY AND AN UNKNOWN GIRL

Open Document