How Far Did the Working Class of Russia Suffer More from Bolshevik (Communist) Rule Than Tsarist Rule During the Years 1855 to 1956?

1530 Words7 Pages
How far did the working class of Russia suffer more from Bolshevik (communist) rule than Tsarist rule during the years 1855 to 1956? Introduction Despite broad continuity there were some variations in experience (eg legalization of trade unions in 1905), deterioration of working class conditions during war (war communism, WWII), and between periods. Strong case to argue conditions worse under bolshevik period, despite their claims. Working conditions FOR Witte - 82 inspectorate - under-12 was illegal, max of 8 hours for kids 12-15 + 1884 further laws, night-work for women and children forbidden, 1897 maximum 11.5 hour working day for all workers Bolsheviks - by 1919 wages were 2% of 1913 levels - workers spent ¾ on food. Wages only improved to pre-war levels after 1928 Despite glorification through propaganda, Internal labour passports Stalin - much harsher conditions - ban on strikes, internal passports, wage differentials and piece rates, tough discipline and forced labour. 12 hour working day in WW2 AGAINST Opportunities for women Bolsheviks - 8 hour working day + introduction of social insurance Kruschev ended forced labour Stalin - Stakhanovites - work hard, better working conditions, also Creches - 50% of Leningrad women by 1937 1874 - trade unions illegal Strikes - 1878-9 St.P cotton mills, then in 1896 around 30,000 refused to work Dramatic rise in number of strikes at end of Stolypin - in 1910 232 strikes in the empire, 2032 in 1912 and over 3000 in first half of 1914 EG Lena Goldfields in 1912 when 500 injured/170 killed by troops In the 1930’s, some improvement of factory conditions eg creches. Mini-judgement: More improvement, but at a price. Under the communists, thy were geared more for industrialization. Under the communists, there was more harsh impact upon working conditions. The improvements under the Tsars were quite modest
Open Document