How Did Katherine Get an Annulment

504 Words3 Pages
Do you agree with the view that the main reason for Henry’s failure to obtain the annulment of his marriage in the years 1525-29 was the determine opposition of Katherine of Aragon? Between the years of 1525-29 Henry tried his hardest to have his marriage annulled with Katherine of Aragon. His grounds for annulment were based on a biblical transcript called Leviticus. In this Transcript, it clearly stated that if a man were to sleep with his brother’s wife then he was to never have a child. Another reason why Henry wanted an annulment was due to his lust for his new found Anne Boleyn, The third reason he wanted an annulment was that Katherine was hitting menopause. This put Henry on edge because he was desperate to have a son due to how scared he was that England could not be correctly ruled by a Woman. His reasons to believe this was due to the last queen being Matilda who started the war of the roses. These reasons were not strong and did not give Henry a good case for annulment. This shows how the determined opposition of Katherine of Aragon could be considered as the main reason of the failure in the annulment. Source 4 supports the idea that the determined opposition of Katherine of Aragon could be considered as the main reason of the failure in the annulment. This is because she shows her opposition by refusing to join a nunnery. Even though it would give her and honorary retirement. It states that “Henry’s bullying only increased her determination” This shows how her reluctance slowed down the procedure of being annulled. Source 4 also suggests that Katherine was not powerless to Henry’s plans. The reason for this being that Katherine had a strong link to her nephew Charles V who at the time had control over the pope. The pope was the only figure who could directly give an annulment. With the pope being under the control of Charles V, Henry was worried
Open Document