Father Flynn Innocent

281 Words2 Pages
You are innocent until proven guilty, and while it is impossible to prove Father Flynn completely innocent, there is sufficient evidence to indicate he may be innocent. The common damning evidence against Flynn is easily disputed. 1. Why would Sister James smell alcohol on the boy's breath if Father Flynn hadn't given it to him? Sister James never says that the boy was drunk, only that she smelled alcohol on his breath. This was from earlier, before school had begun, and Father Flynn called him to talk to him about it. The fact that alcohol was on the boy's breath but lack of intoxication is actually for Father Flynn's innocence. 2. Why did Father Flynn resign if he was innocent? Why didn't he call Sister Aloysius' bluff? That he would resign because of a bluff is foreshadowed earlier in the movie, when Father Flynn gives a sermon about gossip. Father Flynn likens the influence of gossip to gutting a pillow and throwing its feathers to the wind. No matter how hard you try, you will never recover all of them. Father Flynn understands that even the suggestion that he has had an inappropriate relationship with a boy is enough to irreparably damage his reputation and position within the church. Even if he had challenged and defeated Sister Aloysius' accusations, all of the "feathers" would never be recovered. There is certainly enough doubt in Father Flynn's accusation to say that he is not guilty, and every bit of evidence against him is strictly circumstantial. Sister Aloysius' claim that if her lie was not backed by some truth Father Flynn would have not resigned is defeated by his earlier sermon on
Open Document