Explicating Jonathan Safran Foer’s “a Primer for the Punctuation of Heart Disease”

1011 Words5 Pages
Year 11 Analytical Essay Explicating Jonathan Safran Foer’s “A Primer for the Punctuation of Heart Disease” Jonathan Safran Foer’s “A Primer for the Punctuation of Heart Disease” paints a bleak portrait of a dysfunctional family, and meditates on the reality that insufficient communication within families will not solve problems, but only strain family relationships, even to the extent of eroding familial ties. Through the narrator’s sardonic tone and excerpts of mostly silent familial conversations, Foer mocks and highlights the lack of communication between the family members and argues that remaining silent, repressing disagreeing emotions and misrepresenting latent feelings are sure-fire methods of tainting healthy relationships. Foer labels scarce communication as the hallmark of dysfunctional family relations, and suggests that in order to minimize familial tension and salvage deteriorating family relationships, one must articulate their thoughts and emotions with clear intent. In “A Primer for the Punctuation of Heart Disease”, Foer writes from the narrative perspective of Jonathan, a young male whose family has suffered forty-one heart attacks. The passage features narration interspersed with excerpts of conversations between the family members. Jonathan describes various punctuation marks, the most prominent being the “silence mark”, which Jonathan dubs a “staple of familial punctuation” (135). The noun “staple” not only mocks the alarming frequency at which silences occur in his family, but also insinuates that silence has dominated their family conversation for generations, becoming a defining characteristic of their family dynamic. Jonathan also likens intentional silences with “building a wall over which you can’t climb […] against which you break the bones of your hands and wrists” (136). By comparing the effect of silences to sustaining painful

More about Explicating Jonathan Safran Foer’s “a Primer for the Punctuation of Heart Disease”

Open Document