Patty Kelly's Enough Already, It's Time To Decriminalize Prostitution?

458 Words2 Pages
As an assistant professor of anthropology at Washington State University who had recently studied the commercial sex trade via a trip to a Mexican brothel, Patty Kelly wrote an essay. “Enough Already, It’s Time to Decriminalize Prostitution,” is Kelly’s response to the 2008 resignation of Senator Eliot Spitzer - a man who was found to be utilizing the services of prostitutes despite being elected upon a political platform of “ethics and integrity” and proudly touting his history as a lawyer who had successfully prosecuted various prostitution rings. Despite illustrating her clear opinion that prostitution should be decriminalized in American law, Kelly fails to demonstrate that Spitzer’s illegal actions, and the subsequent public outcry demanding…show more content…
While Kelly’s belief about the merits of decriminalization is adamant and the piece is well written and supported by her own research, the focus of the essay does not lead the reader to question the call for Spitzer’s resignation and/or impeachment. The effects of decriminalization in other countries and the question of the morality surrounding sex for money leave one wondering about the relevance of the addition of Spitzer’s story. Clearly the emotions of the American public in response to the senator’s indiscretions were founded moreso on the hypocrisy of his actions rather than the actions independently. As a whole, the essay does implore the reader to evaluate the value of legislation criminalizing prostitution and determine that there is proof that this legislation has become antiquated in the common day. Unfortunately, the essay does not address the core of the distress that was felt by the American people during the life of this scandal nor force one to question if illegally purchasing sex for money is sufficient grounds for resignation from political office. The real issue at hand in the Spitzer scandal lies with Americans once again being disappointed by a dishonest politician rather than the morality behind a senator's decision to solicite

More about Patty Kelly's Enough Already, It's Time To Decriminalize Prostitution?

Open Document