Dr. Daedalus Response Paper

633 Words3 Pages
College Writing 02.06.13 Task: Dr. Daedalus Response paper 1. Choose one quote and address the author’s stand on that quote. Slater writes: "Assuming, probably wrongly but assuming nevertheless, that human beings represent some higher form of species adaptation, at least in terms of frontal-lobe intelligence, the brain might find it odd to be rewiring itself to presumably more primitive structures, structures we shed a long time ago when we waded out the swamps and shed our scales and feathers." This quote was discussing Dr. Rosen's idea to add wings, webbed feet, hands and other alterations seeming crazy and unacceptable to human bodies. He believes that in the future humans will evolve with these qualities anyway. Every species has a core that makes them what they are, and we are no different. By making this statement, Slater expressed her own opinion on the alteration of natural appearance of human beings. She doesn’t think that human beings are at the forefront of intelligence and that our brains would not be able to rewire our bodies to their normal states when a wing and some animal parts are added. It’s an “evolutionary insults”. She believes that human beings have gone through an evolution from being animals to human and the plastic surgeon that Dr. Rosen did and wanted to do was to against this tradition. It’s going against the course of nature, which directly contradicted what he had said before at the hospital when visiting his patients. Our brains are complex and would reject this. 2. Choose one quote and express your own point of view. Slater quotes Martha Beck when she talked about her child with Down syndrome: "as dissimilar from me as a mule is from a donkey. He is in ways both obvious and subtle, a different beast." Then she stated her idea: “Is it really that simple, that small? One tiny chromosome serves us from the human species? One
Open Document