'Compare and Contrast Modernisation Theory and Dependency Theory, What If Anything Do the Have in Common? by Mj Rice

1909 Words8 Pages
Dependency theory and modernisation theory are two of the dominant post-colonial theoretical interpretations of development. Both theories have been influenced by significant global, political events and key intellectual figures in the field of development and the social sciences. In this essay I am going to present and explain three of the key contrasting arguments visible in dependency theory and modernisation theory. Dependency theory is a critique of modernisation theory and the global capitalist system in which the west has encouraged it be administered by the developing world. These two theories therefore characteristically contrast with one another. However, this essay will also argue that there is an underlying commonality that can be viewed. The first contrast studied in this essay will be the way in which both theories view the effects of colonialism on the developing world, based upon their epistemological stance. Argentina’s president Nestor Kirchner once noted at a summit that “In reference to Neo-liberalism… ‘US policy not only generated misery and poverty but also a great social tragedy that added to institutional instability in the region, provoking the fall of democratically led governments’.”(Gibbs, 2006, pg.275).This demonstrates the split in opinion between the neo-liberal, US influencers of modernisation theory and the post colonial, Latin-American and western influencers of dependency theory. It will be argued that this contrast in the two theories is the most important. The second contrast shown in this essay will be the difference in opinion held regarding the role the state ought to play in creating economic and social development. Thirdly, modernisation theory uses the industrial revolution in England as its blueprint for development. Dependency theory offers no suggestion or actual plan for good development. Finally this essay will show the

More about 'Compare and Contrast Modernisation Theory and Dependency Theory, What If Anything Do the Have in Common? by Mj Rice

Open Document