Churchills Views on Russia

536 Words3 Pages
History – 30 marks Josh Edwards Sources A and E have very opposing views. Source A shows a very negative view, criticising Churchill and his beliefs whilst source E suggest that communism was a real threat and that Churchill’s views are justified. Source A shows Churchill’s views of communism to be unjustified, even suggesting that he puts that over his fear, over his country. The source states: “his vision is haunted by little communist figures”. The use of “little” suggests that the communists are unimportant and no big worry to the British Empire, completely the opposite to source E which shows communists to be “vermin” and “diseased”. Also the word “figures” imply that they are mere toys and have no real substance. Puppets if you will. The source also states: “he’s gripped by a wild vision of black shirts”. “Wild vision” shows how Churchill is looking too far into the future and not focusing on the more pressing issues of post war depression, inflation and unemployment. Whilst this could be seen as true, I know that communism WAS spreading throughout Eastern Europe from the Russian revolution in 1919 especially when the view of source E is concerned. Source E supports Churchill views of Russia, almost aggressively in nature. It says: “Leaders like Typhus-bearing vermin” this is very significant as typhus is a disease caused by bacteria. It is seen as a parasite that can seriously harm humans. So they see communism as a disease or infection, making people ill and spreading across Europe. This shows what the writer thought about communism, a really negative view. The source also says: A Russia of armed hordes with bayonet and cannon”. This implies that communism is a violent, dangerous belief, unlike source A which says that they are merely more than “little figures”. Both some views in source A and B fail to mention any specifics about communism or the
Open Document