By Comparing Bennett’s and Spark’s Portrayal of Young People Growing Up, Discuss How Far Their Texts Portray the Corruption of Youth by Those with Power

975 Words4 Pages
Both Bennett and Spark use their main characters to show how easily influenced young people can be under the influence of somebody they look up to. Bennett uses Hector and Spark uses Miss Jean Brodie. There are a number of similarities between these characters, however the main likeness is that both teachers chose not to follow the conventional teaching method, they would rather not stick to the curriculum and feel that what they choose to show their pupils will ultimately serve a greater purpose and make them well rounded individuals. In “The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie” from the very first page of the novel the girls are singled out and referred to as “the Brodie set”. This shows the reader from the beginning that these girls are different from the rest of the school; they are seen as almost belonging to Miss Jean Brodie. We can see that Brodie picks her “set” very carefully depending on their qualities, this can be seen when she rejects the “delinquent” that is Joyce, she does not want her as part of the group, she only accepts a select few, perhaps those who she can most easily influence and mould into the people she thinks they should be. In the first chapter Miss Brodie says “I am putting old heads on your young shoulders” which shows the reader that she knows that she is influencing them in a way that a teacher should not necessarily be responsible for. She is aware that because of her influence her “set” are different from the rest of the school as she says “all my pupils are the crème de la crème”. She refers to her pupils as this multiple times throughout the novel. This separation from the rest of the school can also be seen in chapter three when Miss Mackay says “There is always a difference about Miss Brodie’s girls and the last two years I may say a marked difference”. Perhaps this recent marked “difference” is because Miss Brodie has become more

More about By Comparing Bennett’s and Spark’s Portrayal of Young People Growing Up, Discuss How Far Their Texts Portray the Corruption of Youth by Those with Power

Open Document