Book Report: Out of Order! Anthony Winkler and White West Indian Writing

1008 Words5 Pages
Out of Order! Anthony Winkler and White West Indian Writing by Kim Robinson-Walcott was a thought-provoking and intriguing book to read because of its skill in literary analysis and insight into the writings of white West Indians. The major focus, author Kim Robinson-Walcott portrays is the idea of race and identity through examining writings of white West Indians, in the Caribbean society, more exclusively in Jamaican society. The author focuses frequently on Anthony Winkler’s two prominent novels The Duppy and The Lunatic and how these novels relate to the trends of identity and racial stereotypes exhibited by other white West Indian writers. The title of the text Out of Order! comes from Kim Robinson-Walcott’s perception that Anthony Winkler’s has an “out of order” stance when it comes to his writing about black and white identity and its relation in the Caribbean as compared to other white West Indian writers. Robinson-Walcott puts forth an argument that when author Anthony Winkler is writing his novels he gives an impression that he is a black man, because of the nature of his writing, when in fact he is white man of Lebanese and Hungarian heritage. While incorporating references to other white West Indian writers, Robinson-Walcott refers to many dynamics such as religion and social activities, for example sex and music in Jamaican culture, that define what the authors are portraying what is to be the essence of West Indian identity. Out of Order! is divided into two parts, the first part entitled “White West Indian Writers and Winkler”. The first section of the text goes on to portray the works of Anthony Winkler and other writers such as Michelle Cliff, Lawrence Scott, H.G. de Lisser, to name a few, in a way that does not reject the work of these writers but she finds the significant ideas about race, color and identity. However, Robinson-Walcott does
Open Document