A Critic Has Written That Women in Tennyson's Poetry Are 'Tragic in Their Lack of Self Determination'. How Far Do You Agree with This Claim?

826 Words4 Pages
A critic has written that women in Tennyson's poetry are 'Tragic in their lack of self determination'. How far do you agree with this claim? Hannah Ellis It could be argued that Tennyson show's women's self determination - their freedom to live as they choose, without the influence of others - in a negative light; many of Tennyson's poems support this belief, such as the poem 'Mariana', however there are also contradictions to this point through poems such as 'From Merlin and Vivien', and there are more ambiguous poems which seem to both agree and disagree with the statement, for example 'The Lady of Shallot'. 'Mariana' is a poem which portrays a theme of isolation throughout; he does this through using the woman Mariana to show the issues with society and lack of connections to society. He does so by describing things in an emotive, melancholic way, for example by describing the moss as 'blackest' and the nails as 'rusted. The Narrator of the poem is not Mariana; the way in which the Narrator is able to 'look on the sweet heaven' where as Mariana 'could not' shows the disconnection of Mariana even between her and the narrator, indicating that she is unable to see things in the same way as others - as if she is unable to escape from her own mind. This feeling of entrapment is shown further through imagery of her enclosed life, such as through mentioning the wall, which encloses her from reality. The form of each stanza takes on a similar format, in almost a chanting fashion - further conveying the monotony of Mariana's life. Furthermore, mentioning of 'the slow clock ticking' further indicates that Mariana is purely sitting and watching time pass before her, rather than trying to do something about her life, which accurately shows Tennyson's portrayal within this poem of women's lack of self determination. On the other hand,

More about A Critic Has Written That Women in Tennyson's Poetry Are 'Tragic in Their Lack of Self Determination'. How Far Do You Agree with This Claim?

Open Document