Free Essays,College Free Essays,Free College Essays at Anti Essays

More people are realizing the failure of bilingual education programs throughout the nation, but still being fought for. California’s Proposition 227 is not only logical, but beneficial to the nations economy and social environment. America should join the majority of California’s voters for this proposition.
California’s Proposition 227 has five key factors which summarize the act. The prop. requires all public schools to be taught in English. Parents may waive this requirement for their children if they prove their child can fluently speak English, has special needs, or if they convince the school board that their child will learn English faster through a different program than the required class. The proposition provides initial short-term placement, averaging around one year, in intensive sheltered English immersion programs for children that cannot fluently speak or comprehend English. The proposition is allowing $50 million per year funding English instruction for individuals pledging to provide personal English tutoring to children in their community. The last key factor is the proposition permits enforcement suits by parents and guardians.
The opposing forces to Proposition 227 consist of the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund (MAL-DEF), the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), the Multicultural Education Training and Advocacy group (META), and other bilingual education supporters. Their main argument is the proposition appears to be discriminating towards non-speaking English students and would cause damage to the children that would be permanent. They believe English immersion is unfair because English speaking students do not have to experience the struggle of learning in a foreign based language. They believe America is afraid of change and the people who are different from the majority population. Proposition goers are accused of linguistic protectionism and using this proposal as an act of...